2. What is some of the evidence that Africans were seafarers?

Answers

Answer 1

Answer: Historians have discovered evidence that suggests Africans were masters at building ships and that it was actually a part of their tradition. Shipbuilding and sailing are over 20,000 years old in the Sahara, and cave wall paintings of ancient ships were displayed in National Geographic magazine years ago

Explanation: im not good at step by step :)

Answer 2

Answer: Some people insist that Africans couldn’t have made it to the New World first simply because

they didn’t have the skill and resources to sail across the Atlantic. As it turns out, that’s

completely false. Historians have discovered evidence that suggests Africans were masters at

building ships and that it was actually a part of their tradition. Shipbuilding and sailing are over

20,000 years old in the Sahara, and cave wall paintings of ancient ships were displayed

in National Geographic magazine years ago. With those shipbuilding skills and the navigation

skills that were noted by other historians of the time, the myth that Africans wouldn’t have been

able to sail to the New World becomes officially debunked. As Dr. Julian Whitewright, a

maritime archaeologist at the University of Southampton, explained, the voyage from Africa on

ancient ships was “quite a plausible undertaking, based on the capabilities of the vessel of the

period and historical material stating it took place

Explanation:


Related Questions

The Columbian exchange took place after.

Answers

Historian Alfred Crosby called the "Columbian Exchange" in the 1970s to describe the massive exchange of people, animals, plants, and diseases between the eastern and western hemispheres after Columbus' arrival in America. I used the term for the first time.

When Europeans crossed the Atlantic, they brought with them plants, animals, and diseases that changed life and landscapes on both sides of the ocean. This two-way exchange between America and Europe/Africa is collectively called the Columbia Exchange.

When Christopher Columbus and his crew arrived in the New World, his two biologically different worlds came into contact. The animal, plant, and bacterial life of these two worlds began to mix in a process called the Columbian Exchange.

Learn more about Columbian Exchange here: https://brainly.com/question/14088518

#SPJ9

During world war ii, psychologists redesigned the layout of instruments in airplane cockpits to help pilots fly safely. this is an example of __________ psychology. a. educational b. industrial/organizational c. human factors d. cross-cultural please select the best answer from the choices provided a b c d

Answers

This is an example of human factors.

What are human factors?

Making the most of these skills by creating tasks and tools that are suitable for people is the focus of a human factors (or ergonomics) approach.

In addition to enhancing their health and safety, doing so frequently guarantees a better run, more efficient organization.

The Five Human Factors technique focuses on analyzing the emotional, social, cultural, cognitive, and physical aspects of a comprehensive consumer experience.

Human factors are significant because they contribute to the efficiency, effectiveness, and safety of work.

Organizations that consider human aspects will make sure the machinery and equipment are simple to operate and secure for their employees.

To learn more about human factors, refer

https://brainly.com/question/25672643

#SPJ4

During world war ii, psychologists redesigned the layout of instruments in airplane cockpits to help pilots fly safely. this is an example of C. human

factors

What is Human factors?

Human factors (HF) is the analysis of how people use technology. It involves the exchange of human capabilities, expectations, and limitations, with work conditions and system design. The term "human factors engineering" (HFE) guides to the application of human factors principles to the design of machines and systems.

Why is human factors necessary?

It is necessary to indicate human factors specifically, because this allows you to identify management to manage these human factors. A barrier to prevent exhaustion has different functionalities than a barrier that prevents erroneous interpretation.

To learn more about Human factors , refer

https://brainly.com/question/25267838

#SPJ4

why had duane scrod sr spent time in jail

Answers

Duane Scrod Sr., a character from Scat by Carl Hiaasen spent time in jail because the transmission of his Tahoe blew and they wouldn't replace it, he was sentenced to 6 months in prison for setting fire to a Chevy store in Port Charlotte.

The mystery of a missing teacher named Mrs. Bunny Starch is told in Scat, Hiaasen's third young adult book, and two of her students, Nick Waters and Marta Gonzalez, will stop at nothing to find her. They make every effort to learn what transpired to their teacher throughout their field trip.

Learn more about Scat here:

https://brainly.com/question/26713545?

#SPJ9

Consider what you know about national and world history.How have nativist and eugenicist ideas continued to influence world events" ?

Answers

Nativist and eugenicist ideas have had a significant impact on world history, both in the past and the present. Nativism is the belief that those who are native to a country or region are superior to immigrants.

They should have a greater voice in political and social affairs. Eugenics is the idea that selective breeding can improve the genetic makeup of a population, resulting in a superior race.

One of the most significant examples of the impact of nativist and eugenicist ideas is the rise of fascist regimes in Europe during the 20th century. Fascist leaders, such as Adolf Hitler, believed that their race was superior to others and sought to eliminate those they deemed as "inferior," resulting in the atrocities of the Holocaust.

Nativist and eugenicist ideas have also influenced immigration policies in many countries, including the United States. The Chinese Exclusion Act of 1882, which banned Chinese immigrants from entering the country, and the Immigration Act of 1924, which restricted immigration from certain regions, were both based on nativist ideas.

More recently, anti-immigrant sentiments have played a role in the Brexit vote and the rise of right-wing nationalist movements in Europe.

Furthermore, eugenicist ideas have influenced policies related to reproductive rights and healthcare, particularly in the context of women's rights and disability rights. For example, forced sterilization was practiced in many countries, including the United States and Germany, as a means of controlling certain populations.

In conclusion, nativist and eugenicist ideas continue to influence world events, and their impact can be seen in political, social, and cultural policies and practices. It is essential to recognize and understand the harmful effects of these ideas and work towards creating a more inclusive and equitable world.

for similar questions on world history

https://brainly.com/question/30149581

#SPJ11

What are the possible responses to fewer resources?

Answers

Resource management provides resource managers with on-demand, real-time visibility into people and other resources, allowing them to exert greater control over delivery.

Effective resource utilization can benefit both employees and employers. It not only ensures that employees have enough work to make their role viable and profitable, but it can also prevent overworking and burnout, resulting in a more balanced work life overall.

Effective resource management entails planning, scheduling, and allocating resources to maximize efficiency. Project managers will need visibility into key performance metrics as well as all details about available resources to accomplish this.

Learn more on  resource-

https://brainly.com/question/17766279

#SPJ9

How did foods from the Americas change the rest of the world? Give at least two specific examples.

Answers

Answer:

Corn (maize), jalapenos

Explanation:

write the information about the continental congress that is asked for an each box

Answers

The Continental Congress was an assembly of representatives from North American rebel colonies that was convened during and after the American Revolutionary War.

Both the Declaration of Independence (1776) and the Articles of Confederation were drafted during this time period (1777)

This is further explained below.

What is a continental congress?

Generally, Before, during, and immediately after the American Revolutionary War, a series of legislative bodies with some executive function came together to form the Continental Congress.

In conclusion, These bodies represented thirteen of Britain's North American colonies as well as the newly declared United States of America.

Read more about continental congress

https://brainly.com/question/3150495

#SPJ1

How many people are needed
to take a loyalty oath in order
for the state to submit a new
constitution and obtain
admittance to the union?

Answers

As per various sources, it can be said that, a state has an estimated 60,000 free inhabited population, in order to obtain membership in the union, and the delegates would ensure the admission into the Congress.

The clause 1 of the section 3 in the Article 4 of the Constitution of the United states, provides the authority of admission of states into the union of U.S.A., and all the new states would get representation on par with other states.
This clause also ensures tht, no state can be broken up into new state, by proving Congress the power and the consent from all the states who are going to be affected by the partition.
one of the most significant and notable point of the clause is the equal footing status, that refers to, the new states would get the equal rights and the powers that are provided to the foundational states in 1778.

To know more about, Constitution of United States, click here-
https://brainly.com/question/12293099


#SPJ4

All of the following were considered to be commoners except __________.
A.
artists
B.
nobles
C.
farmers
D.
merchants

Answers

Answer: b

Explanation:

√x
x
The Spanish who lived and worked in missions often forced Native Americans to
A
B
C
gather food and water for them.
moved farther into the forest areas of the state.
change their languages, religion, and customs.
D fight other colonists for them..

Answers

Answer:

C. change their languages, religion, and customs.

Explanation:

The people living in the Spanish missions wanted to make the Native Americans more like themselves so they forced the Native Americans to change their languages, religion, and customs.

Answer: c

Explanation: because the dictators wanted everyone to be in the spanish religion they either would convert to their religion or die.

The Nuremberg trials were overseen by which of the following

Answers

international judges from each allied nation.

Answer:

Yes, he was reliable.

Explanation:

On the whole, Ibn Battuta is reliable; only his alleged journey to Bulgary was proved to be invented, and there are some doubts concerning the East Asian part of his travels

Compare and contrast gender roles, social
hierarchies, and inequalities within the Islamic
civilization from chapter 13 of Bentley with those
of the Confucian world in Asia

Answers

Answer:

Where is chapter 13

Explanation:

Patriot colonist supported the idea in common sense because thomas paine declared that

Answers

Patriot colonist kept the idea in common sense because thomas paine declared that 'Common Sense,' published in 1776, inspired American colonists to declare independence from England.

How did the colonists respond to Thomas Paine's Common Sense?

Credited with uniting moderate citizens and political leaders behind the idea of independence, “Common Sense” played a tremendous role in transforming a colonial squabble into the American Revolution. At the time Paine wrote “Common Sense,” most colonists believed themselves to be aggrieved Britons.

What ideas did Thomas Paine advance in common sense?

Common Sense made a straightforward case for independence and directly attacked the political, economic, and ideological obstacles to achieving it. Paine relentlessly demanded that British rule was responsible for nearly every trouble in colonial society and that the 1770s crisis could only be determined by colonial independence.

To learn more about Common Sense, refer

https://brainly.com/question/1071053

#SPJ4

what did romans value the most during the early republic? accumulation of wealth accumulation of wealth knowledge knowledge duty to the state duty to the state family family

Answers

Romans value the most during the early republic accumulation of wealth.

What was the greatest contribution made by the Romans?

The Romans invented cement, which was stronger than stone, and used it to build massive arches and domes. They also employed concrete to construct almost 50,000 miles of roadways. This contributed to the empire's unification. Water was transported from the countryside to the city via aqueducts.

How did Romans show their wealth?

Men and women in upper Roman society lavished riches on luxurious villas, lavish entertainment, stylish attire, and entourages of slaves and hangers-on, as well as a variety of valuable personal items: gold jewelry like as earrings, necklaces, and finger rings, and silver mirrors.

To know more about republic :

https://brainly.com/question/28244114

#SPJ4

Match these items.

1. Protestantism
Martin Luther
2. opposed Martin Luther
John Calvin
3. signed law, making Church of England official
theology
4. system of religious beliefs
Separatists
5. wanted to separate themselves from the church
Puritans
6. wanted to purify the Church of England
Elizabeth I
7. taught the elect are saved by grace; Protestant Reformer
Henry VIII
ASK FOR HELP

Answers

Matching the items with what they belongs to are:

1. Protestantism: Martin Luther.

2. Opposed Martin Luther: Henry VIII.

3. Signed law, making Church of England Official: Elizabeth I.

4. System of Religious beliefs: theology.

5. Wanted to separate themselves from the church: Separatists.

6. Wanted to purify the Church of England: Puritans.

What is theology?

Theology can be defined as the process of learning or studying about Christianity by studying the bible to known more about God.

On the other hand Puritans are known as the protester that wanted to purify church of England because the felt that the church was not reformed.

Therefore Protestantism was Martin Luther and Opposed Martin Luther: Henry VIII.

Learn more about theology here: https://brainly.com/question/4320579

#SPJ1

20 POINTSSSS

A time when someone used self-centered listening to listen to me was:

It made me feel:

I find myself doing this to someone else often. True or false? Why?

If true, who do you do it to the most?

Answers

A time when someone used self-centered listening to listen to me was in that statement "If true, who do you do it to the most?".

What is a Self-Centered Listening?

A Self-centered Listening refers to a situation that occurs when you are talking to someone and they only see what you are saying from their point of view.

This listening happens when people see everything from our own point of view. Instead of standing in another's shoes, we want them to stand in ours. Hence, an example of this is seen in sentences like "Oh, I know exactly how you feel" come from. We don't know exactly how they feel, we know exactly how we feel, and we assume they feel the same way we do, like the shoe salesman who thinks that you should like the shoes because he likes them.

Often, the self-centered listening is a game of one-upmanship where people try to one-up each other as if conversations were a competition such as in the following "You think your day was bad? That's nothin'. You should hear what happened to me."

Read more about Self-Centered Listening

brainly.com/question/431494

#SPJ1

Give a summary of the history of Islam, from Muhammad's visions to the Ottoman Empire. 100 points!!

Answers

Answer:

The expansion of the Arab Empire in the years following the Prophet Muhammad’s death led to the creation of caliphates occupying a vast geographical area. Conversion to Islam was boosted by missionary activities, particularly those of Imams, who easily intermingled with local populace to propagate religious teachings. These early caliphates, coupled with Muslim economics and trading and the later expansion of the Ottoman Empire, resulted in Islam’s spread outwards from Mecca towards both the Atlantic and Pacific oceans and the creation of the Muslim world. Trading played an important role in the spread of Islam in several parts of the world, notably southeast Asia.

Explanation: >w<

Answer:

Prophet muhammad (صلاله عليه  وسلام) had a vision of the ottoman empire being conquered by the muslims .There is even a Hadith in which the Prophet (PBUH) prophesied the Atraq, who in Arabic; were the Turks. And at first, when the Mongols had come to power, some scholars of Islam thought that they were the ones who were prophesied. However, the proofs did not add up at all. Then, when the Ottoman Turks came to rule the power, the whole of the Islamic scholars came to the conclusion that they were the ones mentioned in the Hadiths: “The Turks will ride to the inner side of the Arabian Peninsula” and he also said that; “The Turks will be the first nation whom will take the Caliphate from the hands of his Ummah.” This means that, they were nominated a solid candidate among the Muslim peoples for the Muslim Caliphate by the Holy prophet. Also, the Prophet too mentioned once; “Do not fight the Turks, for whoever fights the Turks will lose”.

And of course there is also the famous Hadith: "Verily you shall conquer Constantinople. What a wonderful leader will he be, and what a wonderful army will that army be!" and "The first army that goes on expedition to Constantinople will be forgiven." And so the Prophet Muhammed (PBUH) himself had praised the Turks, and on many occasions, had prophesied their great empires that were to come.

Explanation:

I was born sunni muslim and my explanation is I reviewed and compiled evidence from the noble quran.

Is this true or false? The decision from In Re Gault was that juveniles, when arrested, do not have the same Due Process rights as adults.

Answers

The decision from Re Gault was that juveniles, when arrested, do not have the same Due Process rights as adults. This statement is false.

Gerald Goat's due process and habeas corpus rights were deemed to have been violated by the Arizona juvenile court system by the Supreme Court in 1967, marking a crucial turning point for the nation's juvenile justice system. Juveniles are guaranteed a fair trial just as adults, he added in reference to Re Gault, one of his most significant cases.

Recognizing the importance of the right to due process, courts have determined that juveniles, like adults, should have procedural protections, including the right to counsel, the right to remain silent, the right to be notified of an indictment, and the right to plead.

Know more about Re Gault here

https://brainly.com/question/9783930

#SPJ1

The map shows early North America.

Map of early North America in different shades of green. A dark green bolded area is near Nova Scotia.

Which 1750s settlement does the bolded region of the map depict?

New Spain
New France
New England
New Mexico

Answers

As the Map of early North America in different shades of green but there was a dark green bolded area is near Nova Scotia; the 1750s settlement that the bolded region of the map depict is the New France.

What is the New France?

It referred to the French colony in North America with a capital in Quebec which was founded in 1608. The French colonies of continental North America initially embraced the shores of the St. Lawrence River, Newfoundland, and Acadia.

In conclusion, the New France gradually expanded to include much of the Great Lakes region and parts of the trans-Appalachian West.

Read more about New France

brainly.com/question/7869613

#SPJ1

Answer: New France(B)

Explanation:

EDGE 2023

The Declaration of Independence lists a number of grievances that colonists had with British rule. Which ideal of democratic government do the grievances listed below demonstrate?

For cutting off our Trade with all parts of the world
For imposing Taxes on us without our Consent
For depriving us in many cases, of the benefits of Trial by Jury


a) The government has a responsibility to protect, not violate, the rights of its citizens.

b) The government has the responsibility to distribute wealth equally in the country.

c) The government must uphold the supremacy of national laws over state or local laws.

d)The government must uphold the will of the majority, not the minority, when passing laws.

Answers

The ideal of democratic government that the grievances listed below demonstrate includes:

the government has a responsibility to protect, not violate, the rights of its citizens.the government has the responsibility to distribute wealth equally in the country.the government must uphold the will of the majority, not the minority, when passing laws.

What was the grievances in Declaration of Independence?

In the Declaration of Independence, the grievances refers to the section that was drafted during the Second Continental Congress's Committee which listed the grievances with the actions and decisions of King George III with regard to the Colonies in North America.

Therefore, the Option A,B,D is correct.

Read more about grievances

brainly.com/question/1096246

#SPJ1

Which is NOT a principle of American democracy?

Answers

Explanation:

The question is not comple

who did christianity most appeal to when it was first formed

Answers

Answer:

Explanation:

it was most appealing to the lower classes

Answer:

Paul, or jesus

Explanation:

What impact did the Compromise of 1850 have on California?

It joined the United States as a free state.
It gave up much of its claims of land to the west.
It marked the beginning of the Gold Rush.
It opened up new routes for railroads.

Answers

Answer:

A it joined the US as a free state

Explanation:

Impact that the Compromise of 1850 have on California: It joined the United States as a free state. Thus, option 'A' is the correct option.

Why was the Compromise of 1850 so important?

The Compromise of 1850 was a package of legislation put up by U.S. Senator Henry Clay and approved by the U.S. Congress to resolve a number of slavery-related concerns and prevent the Union from dissolving. Following the election of Zachary Taylor as president in 1848, the debate over whether the territories would be free or slave territory reached a boiling point.

Taylor supported statehood for California in his first annual speech to Congress, and he advocated that "those thrilling themes" that had raised such concerns to be left to the courts. He prevented Henry Clay from moving on with another compromise plan by opposing any legislative proposal that would have dealt with the issues that so infuriated both Northerners and Southerners.

Learn more about the Compromise of 1850, here:

https://brainly.com/question/29761975

#SPJ2

The fact that the astrologer met up with Guru Nayak again is an example of:

A. Irony

B. Farce

C. Tragedy

D.
None of the above

Answers

It is gonna be a and your welcome

sorry I did it wrong the other one dont mind it this is the real one because i forgot the match's
Match the key term to it's definition: 1. Injunction, 2. Labor 3. Capital 4. Blue-collar 5. White-collar

Answers

Answer:

1. is white collar, 2. is capital, 3 is injunction, 4. labor 5. blue collar

Explanation:

Why were Chinese and Indian merchants accepted by Muslim rulers?

Answers

Answer:

Muslim merchants from the Arabian Peninsula had to pass through these islands of the south via the maritime Silk Roads to reach China's ports.

Explanation:

How would you describe Luther's tone in this 1517 document?

Answers

In this document, Martin Luther’s tone was respectful and formal in 1517.

Did the goths do ceremonies in the Roman times?​

Answers

The Goths are a people group that flourished in ancient and medieval Europe. Sometimes referred to as "barbarians", they are known for sacking the Roman city in 410 AD.

The Goths were a nomadic Germanic people who fought against Roman rule in the late 300s and early 400s AD and contributed to the downfall of the Roman Empire, which for centuries dominated most of Europe.

The Goths actually had worship of the god of war, which the Romans identified with Mars, probably related to the proto-Germanic Tīwaz, who might have been called *Teiws in the Gothic language based on their literal names.

Learn more about Goths here: https://brainly.com/question/12792931

#SPJ9

Describe the experiences of women in the New West.

Answers

The lawlessness of the west intended that whilst women had less lawful protection, they have been also now not tightly held down via strict social policies like their Victorian counterparts. They may be prostitutes or brothel madams, yes, however they may additionally be gunslingers, bounty hunters, and enterprise owners.

Ladies held many responsibilities for the duration of the westward growth, which include coping with the movement of households overland, organizing social sports in pioneer settlements, and sharing the difficult exertions of farming new land.

The weather could be very harsh, and settlers also dealt with stressful bugs and threatening animals. Having left pals and family at the back inside the East, many ladies faced homesickness and isolation. In the early years of settlement, ladies skilled many different demanding situations as properly.

Learn more about West here https://brainly.com/question/400122

#SPJ1

Look at this sequence of events labeled 1 through 4.


Steve is arrested for murder.

Steve joins Mr. Sawicki’s film club.

A robbery and murder are committed at the drug store.

Mr. Sawicki testifies at Steve’s trial.

In what order do the events actually happen?


A 1, 2, 3, 4

B 2, 3, 4, 1

C 2, 3, 1, 4

D 3, 4, 1, 2

Answers

The most likely sequence that the order of events actually happened was C 2, 3, 1, 4.

What was the sequence of events?

The first thing that is likely to have happened was Steve joining Mr. Sawicki’s film club. Then there was a robbery and a murder committed at the drug store.

Steve was then arrested for the murder due to some evidence that is not included in the question and then when he was on trial, his employer, Mr. Sawicki, testified at Steve's trial.

Find out more on sequence of events at https://brainly.com/question/906163

#SPJ1

Answer: C) 2, 3, 1, 4 is the correct answer

Explanation:

The person above me is correct!^

2: Steve joins Mr. Sawicki’s film club.

3: A robbery and murder are committed at the drug store.

1: Steve is arrested for murder.

4: Mr. Sawicki testifies at Steve’s trial.

Explanation:

Other Questions
The average temperature in the mountains is 65 in April. The average temperature in that same spot is 5 in December. Determine how much warmer this location is in April than in December, and determine which temperature is the farthest away from 0.\ 65 + |5| = 70, 65 is the farthest from 0 65 |5| = 60, 65 is the farthest from 0 65 + |5| = 70, 5 is the farthest from 0 65 |5| = 60, 5 is the farthest from 0 Simplify each expression. x/ y/ / x/ y/ help you help me find cow and apple? Find the total cost to the nearest cent.$20 haircut; 10% tip A florist buys a dozen roses for $12.96 what is the cost of one rose Paragraph 1 Make a claim about the positive role the Federal Reserve serves in the U.S. economy. Use evidence from your research to support your claim.Paragraph 2 Make a claim about the negative role the Federal Reserve serves in the U.S. economy. Use evidence from your research to support your claim.Paragraph 3 Choose a side. Based on the evidence, which perspective do you agree with more? Write a paragraph to identify your position. Use evidence to explain your choice. Managers have greater influence over organizational performance when relationships with the stakeholders are obvious and secure. true /false .wwwQuickCheckDescribe protons.Location:Charge:Mass: Our school has a complete no phone policy. Should that be a thing? Phones are important, we should be able to have them at all times. x + 4y = 9 solve for x The first three rooms took the painter a total of 9 hours to paint. If the learning curve rate is 85%, how long will it take the painter to paint all 20 rooms in stately wayne manor?. organic life on planet earth emerged under what conditions? a. on geothermal vents in the shallow sea. b. in terrestrial saline ponds . c. in the shallow sea using lightning for energy. d. on geothermal vents in the deep sea. PLEASE HELP I AM DESPERATE I WILL GIVE BRAINLIEST!!!! This political cartoon drawn by John Donaghy appeared in The Daily Graphic on September 16, 1873. The message of this cartoon is reflective of what situation in the late 1800s? A decrease in the number of pizza producers or an increase in the cost of mozzarella cheese used to make pizza will shift theA. demand curve for pizza inward.B. supply curve for pizza outward.C. supply curve for pizza inward.D. demand curve for pizza outward. Which of the following substances tastes bitter and tends to produce hydroxide ions (OH) when mixed with water? [ Brainliest ]In the following explanation, which two body systems are working together to help maintain balanced blood sugar levels?When sugar levels in your bloodstream drop, your pancreas releases a hormone called glucagon. This makes your liver break down the glycogen into glucose which can then make its way into your cells where it can be used for cellular respiration.A. Circulatory and Integumentary SystemsB. Muscular and Skeletal SystemsC. Endocrine and Circulatory SystemsD. Skin and Respiratory Systems in terms of height.9 Modelling The inside of a saucepan has diameter 20 cm and height 13 cm.The manufacturer claims that the pan has a capacity of 4 litres.Is the claim correct?Explain your answer. how does water's polarity help it to dissolve so many substances? (3 points) water's polarity allows it to form covalent bonds with many different substances. water's polarity increases its ability to form ionic bonds with ions and hydrocarbons. water's oppositely-charged ends are attracted to charged ions and polar molecules. water's oppositely-charged ends are able to interact with and dissolve hydrophobic substances. Given your answer to question 13. 04, what can you say about the social cost of production at that point, compared to the consumers marginal benefit? the social cost of production is ______________ than the consumers marginal benefit.